Istanbul, 1922. The Ottoman Empire is falling apart, and modern Turkey is being born out of it. There, in the city between Europe and Asia, Mordechai Weinstein was born — later Mordechai Gazit. In his childhood his family moved to the Land of Israel, then under the British Mandate.
In the 1930s tens of thousands of Jews immigrated, and the Jewish community built institutions, schools and a defence force, the Haganah.
Why it mattered. Gazit’s story begins like that of many of the state’s builders: a child from a distant city who arrives in a land under foreign rule, and within two decades takes part in the struggle to found a state.
A question to think about
How do you build a new life in a new language, in a land still to be fought for?
Why it was hard. The country was caught in tension between Jews and Arabs, and between the community and the British. Young people of his generation grew up between study and security service.
Mordechai’s life
1922
Home and family
Beginnings in Istanbul
Mordechai Weinstein, later Gazit, was born in Istanbul on 5 September 1922, to a Jewish family from Ukraine.
MeanwhileFrom sultanate to republic
Mordechai Weinstein, later Gazit, was born in Istanbul on 5 September 1922, to a Jewish family from Ukraine. He chose the Hebrew name later, the family relates, inspired by Jerusalem’s gazit, the dressed ashlar stone he came to know in his archaeology studies. His brother Shlomo took the name after him. His parents were Tzipora and Ephraim.
His younger brother, Shlomo, would later head IDF Military Intelligence and serve as President of Ben‑Gurion University of the Negev; their elder sister was Sarah.
In the months after his birth in Istanbul, the Ottoman sultanate was abolished on 1 November 1922. The Republic of Turkey was proclaimed on 29 October 1923.
The family immigrated to Mandatory Palestine during his childhood.
MeanwhileLife under British rule
The family immigrated to Mandatory Palestine during his childhood. In a later interview, Shlomo recalled their German-speaking home and how Mordechai and Sarah had already attended school in Turkey and could read and write German.
The family arrived during the British Mandate. Jewish communal institutions developed amid growing tensions between Jews, Arabs and the Mandate authorities, years before the establishment of Israel.
At fourteen Mordechai joined the Haganah, the Jewish community’s underground military organisation.
MeanwhileA generation raised in the underground
At fourteen Mordechai joined the Haganah, the Jewish community’s underground military organisation. It was in the years when, with the outbreak of the Arab revolt in 1936, the Haganah began taking in teenagers for signals and communications units. At the age when teenagers today start high school, he was already a member of the underground. Eleven years later, aged 25, he commanded a company in the battle for al-Qastal.
A fork in the road
Fourteen years old, and an underground that needs every pair of hands.
Take the teenagers in
The price: Schoolchildren in an organisation the British were hunting.
Wait until they grow up
The price: A community with no army left with fewer defenders in the years of the riots.
And what happened?
The community chose the first. A whole generation grew up in the youth units and the Gadna, and he was among the first of them.
The Jewish community had no army, and the Haganah relied on teenagers too. With the outbreak of the Arab revolt in 1936, youth units for ages 14 to 17 were set up alongside it, for signals and communications. In 1941 they were brought together as the Youth Battalions, the Gadna.
In rural settlements almost every boy and girl from 14 belonged, and in the War of Independence it numbered some 18,000 young people. The youngest, aged 12 to 14, helped with communications, fortifications and hospitals.
In 1943 he completed the Haganah officers’ course.
MeanwhileThe Haganah
In 1943 he completed the Haganah officers’ course. In the War of Independence he served as chief intelligence officer of the Etzioni Brigade, the Haganah’s Jerusalem brigade, and then commanded a company. He also earned a master’s degree in archaeology at the Hebrew University.
He was later one of the contributors to the Encyclopaedia Biblica (volume 2, 1954), signing his entries with the Hebrew initials M.G.T. In 1946, two years before the state was founded, he was chosen for the first class of the diplomatic school set up by the Jewish Agency’s Political Department to prepare a foreign service for the state-to-be.
Some 600 candidates applied, and only 25 were chosen. Beside him in class sat Aharon YarivMajor General, former head of Military Intelligence and adviser to the Prime Minister.What they wanted: To use the ceasefire for direct military talks with Egypt, at Kilometre 101.More on Aharon Yariv in “People and events” → and Yehoshafat HarkabiHead of IDF Military Intelligence, 1955–1959; later a professor of international relations.More on Yehoshafat Harkabi in “People and events” →, both later heads of IDF Military Intelligence. The course ran from November 1946 to spring 1948, and the students were also asked to plan the foreign ministry of the state-to-be.
The ministry drew on the document they prepared when it was set up, in May 1948.
A fork in the road
Books or arms?
The university
The price: Giving up a place in the force being built for the struggle ahead.
The underground
The price: Giving up a profession and a civilian future.
And what happened?
In the end he did both: an officers’ course, and a master’s degree in archaeology.
The Haganah was the principal military organisation of the Jewish community in Mandatory Palestine. Its command training and units formed part of the foundation of the Israel Defense Forces in 1948.
In 1946, when a Jewish state began to look possible, the Jewish Agency decided to train in advance those who would represent it in the world. Walter EytanThe first Director-General of the Foreign Ministry, 1948–1959; later Israel’s ambassador to France.More on Walter Eytan in “People and events” →, later the first Director-General of the Foreign Ministry, founded the Institute for Advanced Studies in Jerusalem.
The students did more than study: a group of them, guided by Eytan, prepared a proposal for the structure of the future Foreign Ministry. When the ministry was set up in May 1948, Eytan relied on their document.
The challenge was to build a foreign service for a state that did not yet exist, under British rule and in the midst of a struggle.
29 November 1947. In the streets of Tel Aviv people dance over the partition vote, the UN decision to divide the land into a Jewish state and an Arab state, and in Jerusalem war breaks out at once. Within weeks the city is under siege: the road from the coast runs between Arab villages, and the convoys are caught on it.
In April 1948 fighting raged over al-Qastal, which commanded the road to Jerusalem. In May, as the state was founded, the battle turned to the Jewish Quarter of the Old City, which fell on 28 May.
Why it mattered. The battle for Jerusalem was the battle for the heart of the state-to-be. Without the road to the city it could not be held, and without Jerusalem Israel is hard to imagine. Gazit fought at both decisive points: al-Qastal, which commanded the road, and the Jewish Quarter of the Old City.
A question to think about
How do you hold a besieged city and open the road to it, when every hill along the way is a battle? Gazit, a Haganah commander, was wounded in the fighting for the Quarter.
Why it was hard. Few fighters, few weapons and convoys worn down on the road: every hill and every convoy was a matter of survival.
January 1949, some eight months after he was wounded in the Quarter: Mordechai, Rina and Shlomo. Date and identification as given by the family.
Mordechai’s life
December 1947
Underground and waraged 25
First posting in the Quarter
On 10 December 1947 Gazit entered the besieged Jewish Quarter of the Old City as intended deputy commander, and left after a week.
MeanwhileJerusalem at the outset of war
On 10 December 1947 Gazit entered the besieged Jewish Quarter of the Old City as intended deputy commander, and left after a week.
A fork in the road
A Quarter closing in: go in, or stay out?
Go in
The price: There might be no way out.
Stay out
The price: Leaving the residents and the few defenders on their own.
And what happened?
He went in on 10 December 1947, and left a week later.
After the UN General Assembly’s partition decision on 29 November 1947, fighting spread in Jerusalem and the Jewish Quarter’s defenders needed reinforcement.
After the Palmach, the Haganah’s full-time strike force, took al-Qastal on 3 April 1948, a company of the Etzioni Brigade’s Moriah Battalion held the village under Gazit’s command.
MeanwhileThe struggle for the road to Jerusalem
After the Palmach, the Haganah’s full-time strike force, took al-Qastal on 3 April 1948, a company of the Etzioni Brigade’s Moriah Battalion held the village under Gazit’s command. During a lull in the fighting, one of his sentries shot and killed an Arab fighter. No one knew then who he was.
The next morning the Haganah intelligence service in Jerusalem called to ask about him, and only then did Gazit realise that the dead man was Abd al-Qadir al-HusayniCommander of the “Holy War” forces in the Jerusalem area; killed at Qastal in April 1948.More on Abd al-Qadir al-Husayni in “People and events” →, commander of the “Holy War” forces in the Jerusalem area. Gazit examined the body himself and took his papers.
Asked to send the body to the city, he refused: the Arabs were sniping, and his men had not slept for five nights. The Arab commander’s death was a severe blow to his fighters’ morale. Gazit led the exhausted defenders and asked for them to be relieved; they withdrew on 8 April.
Two days later he wrote to his parents, in English: “I am just back from the Castel where I personally had the honour to throw a hand granate at Abdul Kader Husseini.”
A fork in the road
One hill, and a whole city hanging on it.
Hold at any cost
The price: A few exhausted fighters against a growing force.
Pull back
The price: The road to besieged Jerusalem closes again.
And what happened?
They held for a few days, until they were relieved on 8 April. The road opened for a short time.
The fighting at Qastal formed part of Operation Nachshon and the effort to bring supplies into Jerusalem. Control of the hill overlooking the road changed during the battles; its recapture helped reopen the route temporarily.
On the night of 18–19 May 1948, a force of the Palmach, the Haganah’s mobilised strike force, broke through Zion Gate, and behind it a relief force of about 80 men, loaded with military and medical supplies, entered the Jewish Quarter under Gazit’s command.
MeanwhileJerusalem in the 1948 war
On the night of 18–19 May 1948, a force of the Palmach, the Haganah’s mobilised strike force, broke through Zion Gate, and behind it a relief force of about 80 men, loaded with military and medical supplies, entered the Jewish Quarter under Gazit’s command. It had been gathered from different units in the city: students, Haganah field troops, veterans and checkpoint guards.
The Palmach commanders asked Gazit’s men to take their place in the Quarter so that the Palmach could withdraw. Gazit objected: he had been ordered to hold Mount Zion, and his men had not been trained for the kind of fighting the Quarter demanded. By order of the Jerusalem district commander he was made commander of the Quarter.
At dawn he went out to inspect the positions and was severely wounded by shots fired at him. Until the Quarter fell nine days later, he lay wounded in the Misgav Ladach hospital; some of his men fought to the end and went into Jordanian captivity.
When the Quarter surrendered, on 28 May, to the Arab Legion’s commander in the Old City, Abdullah el-Tell, the men of military age were taken prisoner. The seriously wounded were handed to the Red Cross and moved to Jewish Jerusalem. A month after he was wounded, on 19 June, he wrote to his parents from Bikur Holim Hospital, in English.
He told them he was engaged to Rina, and only at the end added: “I forgot to tell you that I was wounded in the chest (lung)”. The injury ended his combat service and cost him a lung. In a 1980 interview he said it “gave me further impetus to go on in government.”
Yitzhak RabinPrime Minister, 1974–1977; earlier Deputy Chief of Staff and ambassador in Washington.What they wanted: To move step by step, through interim agreements, in return for American guarantees and arms.More on Yitzhak Rabin in “People and events” →, who commanded the Palmach’s Harel Brigade at the time, also came back to that night years later: of the force gathered to enter the Old City, he said in an interview, “Mordechai Gazit … was put in command.”
A fork in the road
Break into the besieged Quarter now, with a small, improvised force?
Break in tonight
The price: Some 80 men gathered from wherever they could be found, without preparation.
Wait for a larger force
The price: The Quarter might fall before it arrived.
And what happened?
They broke in on the night of 18–19 May. Gazit was badly wounded, and the Quarter fell on 28 May.
Jerusalem and its supply routes were a central theatre of the war. The fighting left the city divided: West Jerusalem under Israeli control, and East Jerusalem and the Old City under Jordanian control.
Yehuda Lapidot describes an injury during a dawn inspection after Gazit assumed command. Rami Yizre’el gives the afternoon and says he could not assume command as planned. The discrepancy remains unresolved.
1948. The new state has an army, a government and a flag, but no foreign service. Someone has to open embassies, learn the trade on the job, and persuade a suspicious world that Israel is here to stay.
The first generation of diplomats came from the Haganah, the Zionist institutions and the university, and learned the profession on the job — from London and Rangoon to Washington and Paris.
Why it mattered. In three decades Israel went from a besieged, isolated state to one signing agreements with its neighbours and resting on an alliance with a superpower. People like Gazit built that transition, cable by cable and meeting by meeting.
A question to think about
How do you translate a young state’s needs into the language of diplomacy, and build trust with partners not sure it would survive?
Why it was hard. Israel was small, surrounded by hostility and dependent on the support of great powers; every phrase in a document could carry security implications.
Washington, 1 November 1973. Gazit is at the far right, behind Kissinger.Marion S. Trikosko · Library of Congress
Mordechai’s life
Spring 1949
Research and writingaged 26
From combat to documenting the war
In spring 1949, before moving to the Foreign Service, Gazit joined Eleazar Galili’s team at Maarachot, which researched and wrote the history of the War of Independence.
MeanwhileLearning from the battles
In spring 1949, before moving to the Foreign Service, Gazit joined Eleazar GaliliHeaded the Maarachot team that researched and wrote the history of the War of Independence.More on Eleazar Galili in “People and events” →’s team at Maarachot, which researched and wrote the history of the War of Independence. A year after the fighting, he was already studying the war he had fought.
A fork in the road
Write history before the smoke has cleared.
Write now
The price: The testimony is fresh, but the wounds, and the arguments, are still open.
Wait
The price: Memory fades, and the witnesses scatter.
Gazit joined the young state’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs in 1949.
MeanwhileFrom war to armistice
Gazit joined the young state’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs in 1949. In the 1950s he served in London, where in 1954 he met Sudanese representatives in secret, in one of Israel’s first attempts to break the isolation around it, and in Burma.
In 1955 he headed Israel’s mission in Rangoon for four and a half months, between two ministers: David Hacohen, the first minister, had ended his posting, and Yaacov Shimoni was appointed in September to succeed him. From there he reported to Jerusalem that Israel and Burma were among each other’s friendliest states and worked closely together at the UN.
As he put it, they were the only two socialist states in Asia: both were then governed by socialist labour parties, and David Ben-GurionIsrael’s first Prime Minister.What they wanted: A strong state, and allies beyond the ring of hostility.More on David Ben-Gurion in “People and events” → and U Nu became close friends. That year Burma’s prime minister, U Nu, visited Israel, the first Asian head of government to do so.
At the end of the decade he returned to Jerusalem as political secretary and head of the office of Foreign Minister Golda MeirPrime Minister, 1969–1974. Gazit headed her office twice: when she was Foreign Minister in the late 1950s, and as Director-General of the Prime Minister’s Office from 1973.What they wanted: Security for Israel, and peace through direct negotiation, without a return to the 1967 lines.More on Golda Meir in “People and events” →.
In 1950–1951 he was also the Foreign Ministry’s representative on the government committee for holy and historical places, which dealt with preserving sites, tourism and the balance between preservation and development: a meeting point between the antiquities he had studied and the work of the young state. Gazit was also one of those who examined candidates for the foreign service.
Yosef HadassDiplomat, born in Aleppo, later Director-General of the Foreign Ministry; his memoir recalls the talk with Gazit and the Arabic test.More on Yosef Hadass in “People and events” →, born in Aleppo and later Director-General of the Foreign Ministry, recalled in his memoir that after a five-minute conversation Gazit asked the department’s senior researcher, Asher GorenThe senior researcher in the Foreign Ministry’s research department.More on Asher Goren in “People and events” →, to test his Arabic. Goren examined him on al-Ahram, Egypt’s leading daily, and after further interviews he was accepted.
He worked in the Foreign Ministry’s research department from 1949 to 1951, and as early as 1949/50 was running it in practice.
On 9 March 1959, amid the Berlin crisis, Gazit wrote to Meir about Reuven Shiloah’s proposal to explore Israeli links with NATO. He asked her to sound out French sponsorship.
The letter records an exploratory initiative; it provides no evidence of an agreement or membership.
A fork in the road
A year-old state, and a foreign service with no tradition.
Recruit experienced diplomats
The price: There are hardly any, and they do not know the country from within.
Turn fighters into diplomats
The price: Learning the trade on the job, facing seasoned counterparts.
And what happened?
Israel mostly took the second path. Gazit was one of them.
Israel signed armistice agreements with Egypt, Lebanon, Jordan and Syria. The agreements established military demarcation lines, but were not peace treaties—the setting in which the young state’s foreign service worked.
In the 1950s Israel was isolated in Asia. In April 1955 the states of Asia and Africa met at the Bandung Conference, and Israel was not invited. Burma was the exception: full relations from 1953, when the first minister, David Hacohen, arrived in Rangoon, cooperation in agriculture and security, and a friendship between the prime ministers. The challenge for Israel’s representative in Rangoon was to keep that friendship, Israel’s only gateway to the continent.
As head of Foreign Minister Golda Meir’s office, Gazit took charge of one of the painful questions of the day: Morocco, independent since 1956, restricted the departure of its Jews, and Israel was looking for ways to let them emigrate.
MeanwhileLeaving in secret, then by agreement
As head of Foreign Minister Golda MeirPrime Minister, 1969–1974. Gazit headed her office twice: when she was Foreign Minister in the late 1950s, and as Director-General of the Prime Minister’s Office from 1973.What they wanted: Security for Israel, and peace through direct negotiation, without a return to the 1967 lines.More on Golda Meir in “People and events” →’s office, Gazit took charge of one of the painful questions of the day: Morocco, independent since 1956, restricted the departure of its Jews, and Israel was looking for ways to let them emigrate. On 17 June 1959 Gazit sat in a coordination meeting on ways to advance their departure.
When an approach to the crown prince, King HassanKing of Morocco, 1961–1999; before that Crown Prince Moulay Hassan.More on King Hassan in “People and events” →, later King Hassan II, was considered, he was wary: “we must re-examine the matter and check to what extent the prince would be able to keep his promises, if indeed he were ready to make them”. He preferred “at this stage” to take “the normal route”, the diplomatic channel, to influence the king.
Only in 1961, through an agreement with the authorities, did the way open, and tens of thousands of Jews left Morocco for Israel in Operation Yakhin.
A fork in the road
How do you bring a whole community out of a country that will not let it go?
Open pressure
The price: Angering the king, and making life harder for the Jews who stayed.
In secret
The price: Danger to those leaving, as the sinking of the “Egoz” showed.
Quiet diplomacy
The price: A slow road, dependent on promises that might not be kept.
And what happened?
Gazit preferred the diplomatic road at the time. In the end the paths were combined, up to the agreement that made Operation Yakhin possible.
When Morocco became independent in 1956 some 230,000 Jews lived there. Its leaders opposed their departure: they feared for the economy, and for relations with the Arab states at war with Israel. From 1957 to 1961 the “Misgeret”, a network of the Mossad, Israel’s intelligence service, brought Jews out by illegal routes; in January 1961 the boat “Egoz” sank with forty-four emigrants aboard. From late 1961 to 1964, in Operation Yakhin, Jews left with the authorities’ consent, on collective passports.
On 11 July 1960 Gazit arrived in Washington as minister at the embassy, that is, the ambassador’s deputy, succeeding Yaacov Herzog and serving alongside Ambassador Avraham Harman; he had previously headed Foreign Minister Golda Meir’s office.
MeanwhileCloser ties with the United States
On 11 July 1960 Gazit arrived in Washington as minister at the embassy, that is, the ambassador’s deputy, succeeding Yaacov HerzogA diplomat; Gazit’s predecessor as minister at the Washington embassy.More on Yaacov Herzog in “People and events” → and serving alongside Ambassador Avraham HarmanIsrael’s ambassador in Washington, 1959–1968; Gazit was his deputy at the embassy.What they wanted: A close tie to the Kennedy administration, without the Dimona dispute damaging it.More on Avraham Harman in “People and events” →; he had previously headed Foreign Minister Golda MeirPrime Minister, 1969–1974. Gazit headed her office twice: when she was Foreign Minister in the late 1950s, and as Director-General of the Prime Minister’s Office from 1973.What they wanted: Security for Israel, and peace through direct negotiation, without a return to the 1967 lines.More on Golda Meir in “People and events” →’s office. In 1961, from the embassy, he coordinated the first visit of American scientists to the Dimona reactor.
Beside Ambassador Harman he negotiated with the Americans on the Hawk anti-aircraft missiles, which the United States decided in 1962 to sell to Israel. As early as February 1961, at a meeting with McGeorge BundyNational security adviser to Presidents Kennedy and Johnson.More on McGeorge Bundy in “People and events” →, John F. KennedyPresident of the United States, 1961–1963. Gazit wrote a book on his policy.What they wanted: To prevent the spread of nuclear weapons, including at Dimona, and to build ties with the Arab states as well.More on John F. Kennedy in “People and events” →’s national security adviser, he set out Israel’s position on dividing the Jordan waters: the Jordan to Israel, and the Yarmuk to the Kingdom of Jordan.
In January 1964 he sat beside Harman opposite Secretary of State Dean RuskUS Secretary of State, that is, foreign minister, 1961–1969.What they wanted: Regional stability, without direct American involvement in the conflicts.More on Dean Rusk in “People and events” →, when Israel asked the United States for hundreds of tanks. In 1963 he signed on Israel’s behalf to join the Partial Nuclear Test Ban Treaty, and a Geva newsreel caught the moment.
At a farewell reception given for him and his wife by Ambassador Harman in July 1965, it was noted that he had frequently served as chargé d’affaires during his five years in Washington. In his last weeks there he was dealing with one of the conflicts that would lead, two years later, to the Six-Day War.
On 7 July 1965 he raised with Secretary of State Dean Rusk Israel’s concern over a canal being dug in Lebanon.
It was part of the Arab plan to divert the sources of the Jordan, the Hasbani and the Banias, so that their water would not reach Israel and the National Water Carrier it had completed in 1964, and he asked for an urgent American démarche in Beirut.
Two weeks later, at the State Department, he argued that “now is right time from diplomatic point of view” to push the Lebanese into removing the tractors and gradually shelving the entire plan.
In October 1963 he sat beside Justice Minister Dov YosefMinister of Justice.More on Dov Yosef in “People and events” → at a meeting with the US Attorney General, that is, the justice minister, Robert KennedyAttorney General of the United States, 1961–1964; brother of President Kennedy.More on Robert Kennedy in “People and events” →, the president’s brother, as the Jewish Telegraphic Agency (JTA) reported.
A fork in the road
Ask an ally to protect you, and keep a secret from it.
Reveal all about Dimona
The price: Losing freedom of action on the nuclear question.
Keep it ambiguous
The price: American suspicion, and requests for arms that meet hesitation.
And what happened?
Israel chose ambiguity, and still received the Hawk anti-aircraft missiles, its first American weapons.
Security and diplomatic ties between the two countries deepened, alongside disagreements including the Dimona issue. This was the backdrop to Gazit’s work in Washington.
The treaty signed in Moscow prohibited nuclear tests in the atmosphere, outer space and underwater, seeking to reduce radioactive fallout. Underground tests remained outside the ban.
Who would drink the Jordan’s water? In 1955 an American envoy, Eric Johnston, proposed a plan to divide the water between Israel and its neighbours. The Arab states rejected it, and Israel went on building the National Water Carrier, meant to bring water from the Sea of Galilee to the Negev. The challenge for the diplomats in Washington was to keep American support for the project, against Arab pressure to stop it.
Egypt was receiving modern tanks from the Soviet Union, and Israel feared losing its edge on land. Until then the United States had sold Israel only a defensive weapon, the Hawk missiles. The request for tanks was a new test: would Washington agree to sell Israel offensive weapons as well.
Mordechai’s life
1965–1967
Diplomacy and serviceaged 42–44
The Middle East department
On returning from Washington, Gazit took up a senior post at the Foreign Ministry in Jerusalem focused on Middle Eastern affairs.
MeanwhileBefore the Six-Day War
On returning from Washington, Gazit took up a senior post at the Foreign Ministry in Jerusalem focused on Middle Eastern affairs. In February 1967, four months before the Six-Day War, Shlomo HillelA diplomat, later a minister and Speaker of the Knesset.More on Shlomo Hillel in “People and events” → took over from him.
A fork in the road
Reading the neighbours: a real threat, or noise?
Raise the alarm
The price: Spreading panic, and perhaps setting off what you meant to prevent.
Reassure
The price: Missing an early sign of war.
And what happened?
In May 1967 it became clear how thin the line was.
On 23 February 1966 Gazit wrote a survey of the quiet tie with the Shah’s Iran: oil, trade and security cooperation, without official relations.
MeanwhileEnergy and regional relations
On 23 February 1966 Gazit wrote a survey of the quiet tie with Mohammad Reza Shah PahlaviThe Shah of Iran, 1941–1979; overthrown in the Islamic Revolution.More on Mohammad Reza Shah Pahlavi in “People and events” →’s Iran: oil, trade and security cooperation, without official relations. In it he defined the relations as “a kind of unwritten secret alliance”, giving Israel advantages in the economy, in security and against Nasserism. The historian Uri BialerA historian of Israel’s foreign policy.More on Uri Bialer in “People and events” → cites it in his research.
A fork in the road
An ally that embraces you in secret and denies you in public.
Deepen the tie
The price: Investing in a regime that might fall.
Keep a distance
The price: Giving up a rare partner in a hostile region.
And what happened?
The alliance lasted, until the revolution of 1979.
After Washington he returned to Jerusalem, and in the year before the Six-Day War, as Deputy Director-General of the Foreign Ministry, he was the ministry’s point man for the effort to resume El Al flights over the Straits of Tiran, halted since 1955.
MeanwhileThe straits, at sea and in the air
After Washington he returned to Jerusalem, and in the year before the Six-Day War, as Deputy Director-General of the Foreign Ministry, he was the ministry’s point man for the effort to resume El Al flights over the Straits of Tiran, halted since 1955.
Memoranda from El Al, from his assistant Uri Berger and from Foreign Minister Abba EbanForeign Minister, 1966–1974.What they wanted: To present Israel to the world as a country seeking peace, and to win support for it.More on Abba Eban in “People and events” → reached his desk, and on 4 January 1967 he and Naftali Ben-Yehuda of the Transport Ministry sent a joint letter to the Foreign Minister and the Minister of Transport. Five months later Gamal Abdel NasserPresident of Egypt, 1956–1970.More on Gamal Abdel Nasser in “People and events” → closed the straits.
The historian Eitan Barak reconstructed the affair from the file at the State Archives.
A fork in the road
A right on paper, against a danger in the air.
Fly
The price: Risking an incident with Egypt.
Quietly give it up
The price: A right left unused wears away.
And what happened?
In May 1967 Egypt closed the straits to Israeli shipping, and war broke out.
The Straits of Tiran are Eilat’s gateway to the Red Sea. After the 1956 Sinai war, in which Israel briefly took the peninsula, they opened to Israeli shipping, but in the air, the research shows, Israel never enjoyed the same freedom. In May 1967 Gamal Abdel NasserPresident of Egypt, 1956–1970.More on Gamal Abdel Nasser in “People and events” → closed the straits, and Israel saw it as a cause for war.
Adviser, immigrant absorption, and back to the Foreign Ministry
After the Middle East department, Gazit served as an adviser at the Foreign Ministry and head of its special-assignments division.
MeanwhileA new ministry for immigrant absorption
After the Middle East department, Gazit served as an adviser at the Foreign Ministry and head of its special-assignments division. “I was thinking of a sabbatical and of writing a study, but the war got in the way a little,” he later told the Agranat Commission, the inquiry into the Yom Kippur War.
The war reached home, too: the family recalls that on its first day, 5 June 1967, he learned through his duties, as events unfolded, that his nephew, the pilot Dan Engel, his sister Sarah’s son, had been killed. His grandson Dan-Eyal is named, in part, after him.
At the end of 1968 he moved to the Ministry of Immigrant Absorption, and until May 1970 he was its deputy director-general, in the years when Israel was absorbing the wave of immigration that followed the Six-Day War. The ministry had been founded only months earlier, under Yigal AllonDeputy Prime Minister, and Foreign Minister in Rabin’s government.What they wanted: Defensible borders, and a territorial compromise with Jordan (the “Allon Plan”).More on Yigal Allon in “People and events” →, and Gazit was one of its first senior civil servants.
His appointment as deputy director-general was announced in May 1969. He then returned to the Foreign Ministry as deputy director-general responsible for relations with the United States and Canada.
The Ministry of Immigrant Absorption was established in 1968, with Yigal AllonDeputy Prime Minister, and Foreign Minister in Rabin’s government.What they wanted: Defensible borders, and a territorial compromise with Jordan (the “Allon Plan”).More on Yigal Allon in “People and events” → as its first minister.
Four years after the Soviet Union broke off relations with Israel, Gazit sat across from its envoys in a secret channel, Yevgeny Primakov among them, and passed the reports directly to Golda Meir.
MeanwhileSevered relations
Four years after the Soviet Union broke off relations with Israel, Gazit sat across from its envoys in a secret channel, Yevgeny PrimakovSoviet orientalist and envoy in the secret channel to Moscow; later Prime Minister of Russia.What they wanted: To test whether Israel could be influenced without renewing relations, and to strengthen Moscow’s place in the peace process.More on Yevgeny Primakov in “People and events” → among them, and passed the reports directly to Golda MeirPrime Minister, 1969–1974. Gazit headed her office twice: when she was Foreign Minister in the late 1950s, and as Director-General of the Prime Minister’s Office from 1973.What they wanted: Security for Israel, and peace through direct negotiation, without a return to the 1967 lines.More on Golda Meir in “People and events” →.
A fork in the road
Talk to the power arming the enemy?
Talk, in secret
The price: Arousing suspicion in Washington, the main ally.
Stay silent
The price: Perhaps missing a shift in Moscow’s position.
And what happened?
The contacts went on in secret, and continued even after an Austrian paper exposed them in April 1975. No breakthrough came.
In these years Gazit stood at the heart of Israel’s decision-making: at the head of the Foreign Ministry, and then at the head of the Prime Minister’s Office, as political adviser to two prime ministers.
Meanwhile“Golda’s kitchen”
In these years Gazit stood at the heart of Israel’s decision-making: at the head of the Foreign Ministry, and then at the head of the Prime Minister’s Office, as political adviser to two prime ministers. In 1972 he headed the Foreign Ministry as its Director-General.
On 5 September 1972, the day of the massacre of the Israeli athletes at the Munich Olympics, the ambassador in Washington, Yitzhak RabinPrime Minister, 1974–1977; earlier Deputy Chief of Staff and ambassador in Washington.What they wanted: To move step by step, through interim agreements, in return for American guarantees and arms.More on Yitzhak Rabin in “People and events” →, reported to him on his conversation with Secretary of State William RogersU.S. Secretary of State, that is, foreign minister, 1969–1973.What they wanted: A comprehensive American peace plan, and first of all a ceasefire in the War of Attrition.More on William Rogers in “People and events” →. The next day the two exchanged cables on the American position on halting the Games.
On 15 March 1973 he entered Golda MeirPrime Minister, 1969–1974. Gazit headed her office twice: when she was Foreign Minister in the late 1950s, and as Director-General of the Prime Minister’s Office from 1973.What they wanted: Security for Israel, and peace through direct negotiation, without a return to the 1967 lines.More on Golda Meir in “People and events” →’s office as Director-General of the Prime Minister’s Office and her political adviser, succeeding Simcha DinitzIsrael’s ambassador in Washington from 1973.What they wanted: American arms and support, during the war and after it.More on Simcha Dinitz in “People and events” →, who left to serve as ambassador in Washington.
From that day he sat in “Golda’s kitchen”: the small forum of the Prime Minister and her senior ministers, where the important decisions took shape before they were brought to the cabinet. He kept the post under Yitzhak Rabin.
On 18 April 1973 he sat in the discussion of whether Egypt and Syria were about to attack, one of the three war “alarms” he later counted in his testimony to the Agranat Commission, the inquiry into the Yom Kippur War. In the spring of 1973 Henry KissingerU.S. National Security Adviser and Secretary of State.What they wanted: To push the Soviet Union out of the Middle East and make the United States the only broker, through step-by-step agreements.More on Henry Kissinger in “People and events” → held secret contacts with Hafez IsmailNational security adviser to Egypt’s President Sadat. In 1973 he conducted secret contacts with Kissinger on Sadat’s behalf.More on Hafez Ismail in “People and events” →, the national security adviser of Egypt’s President Anwar SadatPresident of Egypt, 1970–1981.What they wanted: To get Sinai back for Egypt, and move Egypt from Soviet to American patronage.More on Anwar Sadat in “People and events” →.
Gazit sent Ambassador Dinitz cables on the matter on 13 and 15 May, the second conveying Golda Meir’s comments. Five days later, on 20 May, Kissinger and Ismail met for the second time, near Paris. In the secret cables between Jerusalem and Washington, Kissinger went by the code name “Shaul”.
In a letter to Dinitz that spring Gazit wondered whether Kissinger was telling Israel everything that passed in the channel, and wrote: “Quite a few questions remain unanswered, and some doubts gnaw at our hearts”.
In 2019 three scholars published an article on this channel in an international journal of intelligence studies, and named it after his file: “Kissinger’s Lost Peace: The Gazit File”. In June 1973, during Chancellor Willy BrandtWest German chancellor, 1969–1974, and Nobel Peace Prize laureate; visited Israel in June 1973.What they wanted: Close ties with Israel alongside closeness to the Arab states: a “balanced policy”.More on Willy Brandt in “People and events” →’s visit, he briefed the press in English, stressing that Israel had no objection to friendly nations maintaining good relations with the Arab states.
After the visit a secret channel for messages opened between Meir and Brandt, and Gazit ran it: in August 1973 he explained its nature in a letter to Israel’s ambassador in Bonn. Two months later war broke out, and his office became the meeting point between Jerusalem and Washington.
Of the American airlift, the transport planes that brought Israel arms and ammunition in the middle of the war, he later said: “The airlift was decided not because we asked for it.” On the morning of 6 October he left in the middle of the meeting at the Prime Minister’s to arrange her meeting with the American ambassador, Kenneth KeatingUnited States ambassador to Israel, 1973–1975.More on Kenneth Keating in “People and events” →.
It was he who proposed that Israeli and Egyptian officers negotiate face to face, at the Kilometre 101 talks, held at a point on the Cairo–Suez road where officers of the two armies met. He told the story in an interview with the historian Ken SteinAn American historian of the Middle East; interviewed Gazit.More on Ken Stein in “People and events” →.
In December 1973 he coordinated the expert teams ahead of the Geneva Conference, and in January 1974 he worked on the wording of the disengagement agreement with Egypt. On 6 December 1973 he testified before the Agranat Commission and told it: “Every Jew must ask himself where he erred.”
On 26 March 1974 he submitted three memoranda to Golda Meir under a signed covering letter: a survey of the American National Security Council, a proposal for a small national security policy staff in the Prime Minister’s Office, and a separate discussion of competing intelligence assessments.
The proposed staff would prepare alternatives and coordinate information; intelligence assessments and warnings would remain with the intelligence community. The annexes are unsigned and undated. The file establishes his submission of the proposal, but does not show that it was adopted or that he alone wrote the annexes.
The State Archives hold a file titled “Meetings with the Prime Minister recorded by M. Gazit”, with summaries and minutes from April 1973 to September 1974.
A fork in the road
What reaches the prime minister’s desk, and what stays outside?
Filter and summarise
The price: The risk that something important will not get through.
Pass on everything
The price: A prime minister drowning in information at the moment of truth.
“Golda MeirPrime Minister, 1969–1974. Gazit headed her office twice: when she was Foreign Minister in the late 1950s, and as Director-General of the Prime Minister’s Office from 1973.What they wanted: Security for Israel, and peace through direct negotiation, without a return to the 1967 lines.More on Golda Meir in “People and events” →’s kitchen” was the small forum in which Golda Meir shaped the important decisions. On Saturday nights, before the Sunday cabinet meeting, a handful of ministers met at her home: Moshe DayanDefence Minister, 1967–1974, and Foreign Minister, 1977–1979.What they wanted: Defensible borders; and after 1977, as foreign minister, peace with Egypt.More on Moshe Dayan in “People and events” →, Yigal AllonDeputy Prime Minister, and Foreign Minister in Rabin’s government.What they wanted: Defensible borders, and a territorial compromise with Jordan (the “Allon Plan”).More on Yigal Allon in “People and events” → and Yisrael GaliliMinister without portfolio and one of Golda Meir’s closest advisers.More on Yisrael Galili in “People and events” →, and at times others.
The most sensitive matters were discussed there, among them the secret meetings with King HusseinKing of Jordan, 1952–1999.What they wanted: To keep his kingdom safe between Israel, the Arab states and the Palestinians, and to regain the West Bank.More on King Hussein in “People and events” →, which were never brought to the full cabinet. Gazit, Director-General of her office and her political adviser, was the professional at the table: he recorded the meetings, prepared the papers and drafted the cables.
The challenge for such a man was to serve the Prime Minister loyally and stay out of the struggles between the ministers.
In the worldFebruary–May 1973
The secret channel between Cairo and Washington
Hafez IsmailNational security adviser to Egypt’s President Sadat. In 1973 he conducted secret contacts with Kissinger on Sadat’s behalf.More on Hafez Ismail in “People and events” → was the national security adviser of Egypt’s President Anwar SadatPresident of Egypt, 1970–1981.What they wanted: To get Sinai back for Egypt, and move Egypt from Soviet to American patronage.More on Anwar Sadat in “People and events” →. In July 1972 Sadat expelled the Soviet advisers from Egypt and, through Ismail, opened a direct and secret channel to Henry KissingerU.S. National Security Adviser and Secretary of State.What they wanted: To push the Soviet Union out of the Middle East and make the United States the only broker, through step-by-step agreements.More on Henry Kissinger in “People and events” → at the White House. In February 1973 the two met, and Ismail set out Egypt’s readiness for an agreement with Israel, with demilitarised zones and peacekeeping forces.
Israel responded hesitantly, and the contacts did not ripen. Less than five months after their second meeting, in May, the war broke out. Historians have argued ever since: some see these contacts as a missed opportunity for peace, others hold that the war could not have been avoided.
Gazit himself rejected the missed-opportunity claim in his writings; his position is one side of the debate, not an agreed verdict.
The war began with Egyptian and Syrian attacks on 6 October. Alongside the fighting, efforts to secure assistance and negotiate a ceasefire unfolded in a crisis involving the superpowers.
The morning of the war: strike first, or absorb the blow
Before dawn Jerusalem learned that Egypt and Syria would open war that day. The Chief of Staff, David Elazar, asked for full mobilisation of the reserves and a pre-emptive air strike.
Golda MeirPrime Minister, 1969–1974. Gazit headed her office twice: when she was Foreign Minister in the late 1950s, and as Director-General of the Prime Minister’s Office from 1973.What they wanted: Security for Israel, and peace through direct negotiation, without a return to the 1967 lines.More on Golda Meir in “People and events” → approved a broad call-up but decided that Israel would not fire first: she wanted it to be clear to the world, and above all to the United States, who had started the war. She conveyed that decision the same morning to the American ambassador, Kenneth KeatingUnited States ambassador to Israel, 1973–1975.More on Kenneth Keating in “People and events” →.
The challenge for her office in those hours was to mobilise an army and secure Washington’s backing at one and the same time.
The agreement of 18 January provided for withdrawals, force limitations and a UN buffer zone near the Suez Canal. It was a step from war towards a sequence of negotiated arrangements.
On 7 June 1973 Willy Brandt landed in Israel, the first West German chancellor to pay an official visit.
MeanwhileThe chancellor who knelt
On 7 June 1973 Willy BrandtWest German chancellor, 1969–1974, and Nobel Peace Prize laureate; visited Israel in June 1973.What they wanted: Close ties with Israel alongside closeness to the Arab states: a “balanced policy”.More on Willy Brandt in “People and events” → landed in Israel, the first West German chancellor to pay an official visit. While Golda MeirPrime Minister, 1969–1974. Gazit headed her office twice: when she was Foreign Minister in the late 1950s, and as Director-General of the Prime Minister’s Office from 1973.What they wanted: Security for Israel, and peace through direct negotiation, without a return to the 1967 lines.More on Golda Meir in “People and events” → and Brandt met alone, Gazit led the Israeli delegation in talks with the German delegation. He welcomed Bonn’s dialogue with the Arab states but, unlike his German counterpart, did not judge the situation in the Middle East to be dangerous.
Four months later the Yom Kippur War broke out.
On the evening of 10 June he approached Klaus Harpprecht, Brandt’s friend and adviser: he remarked on a “certain non-committal quality” in the chancellor’s words about Israel’s will for peace, recalled that “even Richard NixonPresident of the United States, 1969–1974.What they wanted: Stability in the Middle East and a check on Soviet influence, without a direct clash between the powers.More on Richard Nixon in “People and events” →” had clearly recognised it, and asked that Brandt let Golda know he wanted a “direct correspondence” with her, without the German Foreign Office. Before his flight, Brandt asked Golda how he could reach her directly.
A fork in the road
Friendship with Germany, twenty-eight years after the Holocaust.
Ask for clear words
The price: Pressing a chancellor who is also courting the Arab states.
Settle for what there is
The price: A “balanced” Germany, and a Europe drifting away.
And what happened?
Brandt asked Golda how he could reach her directly, and in the summer of 1973 they kept up a secret exchange.
Willy BrandtWest German chancellor, 1969–1974, and Nobel Peace Prize laureate; visited Israel in June 1973.What they wanted: Close ties with Israel alongside closeness to the Arab states: a “balanced policy”.More on Willy Brandt in “People and events” →, who fled Nazi Germany as a young man, was West German chancellor from 1969 to 1974. In December 1970 he knelt before the memorial to the heroes of the Warsaw Ghetto uprising, and the next year he won the Nobel Peace Prize. His 1973 visit was the first to Israel by a serving German chancellor, twenty-eight years after the Holocaust.
In April 1974 Golda Meir announced her resignation, and in June Yitzhak Rabin entered the Prime Minister’s Office.
MeanwhileA change of prime ministers
In April 1974 Golda MeirPrime Minister, 1969–1974. Gazit headed her office twice: when she was Foreign Minister in the late 1950s, and as Director-General of the Prime Minister’s Office from 1973.What they wanted: Security for Israel, and peace through direct negotiation, without a return to the 1967 lines.More on Golda Meir in “People and events” → announced her resignation, and in June Yitzhak RabinPrime Minister, 1974–1977; earlier Deputy Chief of Staff and ambassador in Washington.What they wanted: To move step by step, through interim agreements, in return for American guarantees and arms.More on Yitzhak Rabin in “People and events” → entered the Prime Minister’s Office. Gazit stayed where he was: Director-General of the office and political adviser to the new Prime Minister. Between the two governments, in May and June 1974, he represented Israel at the signing of the agreement with Syria in Geneva, alongside Major General Herzl ShafirIDF major general; appointed with Gazit to represent Israel at the Geneva Peace Conference in 1975.What they wanted: Security arrangements that would hold on the ground.More on Herzl Shafir in “People and events” →.
In September 1974 he sat beside Rabin at the White House, opposite President Gerald FordPresident of the United States, 1974–1977.What they wanted: To continue Kissinger’s path: a second interim agreement between Israel and Egypt.More on Gerald Ford in “People and events” →. In March 1975 he sat on the Israeli negotiating team during Henry KissingerU.S. National Security Adviser and Secretary of State.What they wanted: To push the Soviet Union out of the Middle East and make the United States the only broker, through step-by-step agreements.More on Henry Kissinger in “People and events” →’s shuttle between Jerusalem and Aswan, and in June 1975 he returned with Rabin to the Oval Office.
In August 1975, at the end of his term, he travelled to Washington with the Foreign Ministry’s legal adviser, Meir RosenneLegal adviser to the Foreign Ministry.What they wanted: Precise legal texts that leave no opening for readings against Israel.More on Meir Rosenne in “People and events” →, to work on the legal and political wording of the interim agreement. Before the cabinet meeting, ministers raised a toast to him and to his successor, Amos EranDirector-General of the Prime Minister’s Office after Gazit, from 1975.More on Amos Eran in “People and events” →.
In April 1974 the Agranat Commission, the inquiry into the Yom Kippur War, published an interim report. Public protest grew, and Golda MeirPrime Minister, 1969–1974. Gazit headed her office twice: when she was Foreign Minister in the late 1950s, and as Director-General of the Prime Minister’s Office from 1973.What they wanted: Security for Israel, and peace through direct negotiation, without a return to the 1967 lines.More on Golda Meir in “People and events” → resigned. Yitzhak RabinPrime Minister, 1974–1977; earlier Deputy Chief of Staff and ambassador in Washington.What they wanted: To move step by step, through interim agreements, in return for American guarantees and arms.More on Yitzhak Rabin in “People and events” →, who had taken no part in the decisions before the war, formed a new government in June. The challenge for the office was continuity: the same negotiation, opposite the same Henry KissingerU.S. National Security Adviser and Secretary of State.What they wanted: To push the Soviet Union out of the Middle East and make the United States the only broker, through step-by-step agreements.More on Henry Kissinger in “People and events” →, with a new prime minister.
After the war the fighting on the Golan Heights went on for months. Henry KissingerU.S. National Security Adviser and Secretary of State.What they wanted: To push the Soviet Union out of the Middle East and make the United States the only broker, through step-by-step agreements.More on Henry Kissinger in “People and events” → shuttled between Jerusalem and Damascus for more than a month, until the agreement was signed in Geneva at the end of May 1974. The challenge was to agree on a line that would stop the fire without giving up the security of the Golan settlements.
On 4 September, Gazit signed the Sinai Interim Agreement in Geneva alongside Major General Herzl Shafir.
MeanwhileA further agreement with Egypt
On 4 September, Gazit signed the Sinai Interim Agreement in Geneva alongside Major General Herzl ShafirIDF major general; appointed with Gazit to represent Israel at the Geneva Peace Conference in 1975.What they wanted: Security arrangements that would hold on the ground.More on Herzl Shafir in “People and events” →. On 22 September, the two also initialled the implementation protocol and maps. These were distinct steps in the diplomatic process that preceded the peace treaty of 1979. Reporting from Geneva described Gazit as head of the Israeli delegation and ambassador-designate to France.
In a 1980 interview he recalled that Anwar SadatPresident of Egypt, 1970–1981.What they wanted: To get Sinai back for Egypt, and move Egypt from Soviet to American patronage.More on Anwar Sadat in “People and events” → refused to let the talks run into 1976, fearing the American election campaign would weaken Egypt’s position. The Muslim day of rest and the High Holidays that fell that September left few working days, so two consecutive 24-hour sessions were needed — a detail he remembered with a smile.
A fork in the road
Give land, oil and passes, and receive less than peace.
Sign
The price: Giving up strategic assets for a commitment alone.
Refuse
The price: A crisis with Washington, a “reassessment” and deadlock.
And what happened?
Israel signed in 1975. Three years later came the Camp David Accords.
The interim agreement, reached through Henry KissingerU.S. National Security Adviser and Secretary of State.What they wanted: To push the Soviet Union out of the Middle East and make the United States the only broker, through step-by-step agreements.More on Henry Kissinger in “People and events” →’s mediation, provided for a further Israeli withdrawal in Sinai and a commitment to resolve the conflict peacefully. It preceded the peace treaty signed four years later.
As early as September 1975, in the days of the Geneva signing, the press called him “ambassador-designate to France”.
MeanwhileThe peace treaty with Egypt
As early as September 1975, in the days of the Geneva signing, the press called him “ambassador-designate to France”. On 23 December 1975 he was appointed ambassador, and until 1979 he represented Israel in Paris.
These were hard years in the relationship: the hijacking of an Air France plane to Entebbe in Uganda, which ended in the rescue operation; the crisis over the release of Abu DaoudA leader of Black September; suspected of planning the massacre of the Israeli athletes in Munich in 1972.More on Abu Daoud in “People and events” →, one of the planners of the massacre of Israeli athletes at the Munich Olympics; and the struggle over the reactor France was building for Iraq, which Israel finally bombed in 1981.
After the Abu Daoud affair Gazit was recalled to Jerusalem in protest, and within a month he was sitting opposite the President of France at the Élysée Palace. Largely thanks to his work, relations returned to normal relatively quickly.
During the Entebbe hijacking he conducted the contacts with the French government; in those same days his younger brother, Shlomo GazitHis brother. IDF Major General and head of Military Intelligence, 1974–1978.More on Shlomo Gazit in “People and events” →, headed IDF Military Intelligence. He tried to prevent French help for the Iraqi reactor, and told Foreign Minister Louis de GuiringaudForeign Minister of France, 1976–1978.More on Louis de Guiringaud in “People and events” →: “Whoever supplies the Iraqis with proven fuel is like one who supplies meat to lions”.
In early 1979, thirty days after the death of Shlomo FriedrichHerut’s man in France, who headed the “France–Israel Alliance Committee” for more than twenty years; Gazit spoke in his memory in 1979.What they wanted: An alliance between Israel and France, and support for Israel across the French political spectrum.More on Shlomo Friedrich in “People and events” →, Gazit spoke in his memory. Friedrich, a man of Herut, Menachem Begin’s opposition party, and an old friend of Begin, had headed the “France–Israel Alliance Committee” for more than twenty years, building ties with French politicians across the spectrum.
“We all knew he was a party man,” Gazit said, “and yet no one thought of him as a party man”; the secret of his influence, he added, was “his integrity, his goodness and his generosity” (translated from the French, as quoted in Yoel Haddad’s article).
A photograph of him with the singers Rika Zaraï and Enrico Macias is kept in the Getty archive, taken, according to the archive caption, at an evening event in Paris on 29 May 1976.
And in its farewell item of 5 July 1979, Le Monde described the impression he left: he learned French with surprising speed, and his courtesy and good grace won him sympathy and esteem, even when there were political disagreements. (The sources differ on when he actually took up the post, late 1975 or 1976.)
A fork in the road
An ambassador in a capital that had drifted away.
Protest loudly
The price: Doors that close, and influence that is lost.
Keep the connection
The price: Looking as though you are letting things pass.
And what happened?
He did both: he was recalled to Jerusalem in protest, and came back to Paris to talk.
The peace treaty was signed in Washington on 26 March, following the Camp David Accords. It provided for an end to the state of war, diplomatic relations and Israel’s withdrawal from Sinai, following the earlier agreements.
The 1980s. The state’s archives begin to open the files of its first years, and what was secret becomes material for research. Among the researchers are some who sat in the rooms themselves, Gazit among them.
Gazit joined Harvard and the Truman Institute at the Hebrew University, and wrote on the peace process, on John F. KennedyPresident of the United States, 1961–1963. Gazit wrote a book on his policy.What they wanted: To prevent the spread of nuclear weapons, including at Dimona, and to build ties with the Arab states as well.More on John F. Kennedy in “People and events” →’s policy and on mediation in the conflict.
Why it mattered. The men of action who wrote their own history did so from the documents, not only from memory. The debates he waged, on 1948 and on the years before 1973, are part of how Israel understands itself to this day.
A question to think about
How do you turn personal experience into knowledge others can check, when the writer himself was a party to the events?
Why it was hard. Someone who stood at the heart of events knows things that are not in the documents, but must also contend with personal memory and his own views.
Motke and Shlomo, at Motke’s 90th birthday, as the family remembers it.
Mordechai’s life
From 1980
Research and writingfrom 58
From diplomacy to research
In 1980, after 31 years of service, Gazit took early retirement from the civil service and chose research.
MeanwhileThe end of the Cold War
In 1980, after 31 years of service, Gazit took early retirement from the civil service and chose research. He became a fellow at Harvard’s Center for International Affairs, and the family relates that in the same period he also taught for about half a year at Brandeis University.
At one of the world’s oldest and most prestigious universities he researched John F. KennedyPresident of the United States, 1961–1963. Gazit wrote a book on his policy.What they wanted: To prevent the spread of nuclear weapons, including at Dimona, and to build ties with the Arab states as well.More on John F. Kennedy in “People and events” →’s Middle East policy, a period he had lived through at the embassy in Washington. That research became his book on Kennedy’s policy toward the Arab states and Israel.
As a scholar, too, he stayed loyal to Golda MeirPrime Minister, 1969–1974. Gazit headed her office twice: when she was Foreign Minister in the late 1950s, and as Director-General of the Prime Minister’s Office from 1973.What they wanted: Security for Israel, and peace through direct negotiation, without a return to the 1967 lines.More on Golda Meir in “People and events” →, under whom he had headed both the Foreign Ministry and the Prime Minister’s Office. When she was accused after the Yom Kippur War of having missed a chance for peace, he came to her defence in lectures and articles, arguing from the documents that no opportunity had been missed.
Henry KissingerU.S. National Security Adviser and Secretary of State.What they wanted: To push the Soviet Union out of the Middle East and make the United States the only broker, through step-by-step agreements.More on Henry Kissinger in “People and events” →, across from whom Gazit had sat in the negotiating rooms of 1973–1975, had once worked at the same center. He saw research as an extension of his career rather than a departure from it: a practitioner, he said, could offer political science a different angle from a theorist’s.
Of his archaeology degree, he recalled that the war led him to keep “serving the new state rather than minding my own little shop.” His books and articles examined negotiation, Kennedy’s policies, and Israel’s relations with the United States and its neighbours.
His first two books appeared in 1983: one on the peace process of 1969–1973, the other on President Kennedy’s policy toward the Arab states and Israel. In 1993 he published the essay “Peacemakers”, on mediation in the Arab–Israeli conflict.
Three of his studies appeared in the international Journal of Contemporary History: on the peace talks with King Abdallah IKing of Jordan until his assassination in 1951. Gazit researched the contacts with him.What they wanted: To enlarge his kingdom, even at the price of a settlement with Israel.More on King Abdallah I in “People and events” → (1988), on whether an opportunity for peace with Egypt was missed in 1971 (1997), and on the beginnings of the strategic relationship with the United States (2000).
His book Israeli Diplomacy and the Quest for Peace, published in London in 2002, sets out his research across four decades of diplomacy: from the Bernadotte mediation of 1948, through the Sinai Campaign of 1956, to the London Agreement of King HusseinKing of Jordan, 1952–1999.What they wanted: To keep his kingdom safe between Israel, the Arab states and the Palestinians, and to regain the West Bank.More on King Hussein in “People and events” → and Peres in 1987.
He was a research fellow at the Truman Institute for the Advancement of Peace at the Hebrew University. At the Truman Institute, too, he kept checking facts with people on the other side. In April 1982 he wrote by hand to the lawyer Aziz ShehadehA Ramallah lawyer, one of the first Palestinians to back a Palestinian state alongside Israel openly; murdered in 1985.What they wanted: A Palestinian state alongside Israel, decided by the Palestinians themselves.More on Aziz Shehadeh in “People and events” → of Ramallah, one of the first Palestinians to back a Palestinian state alongside Israel openly.
He sent him material on the question of Palestinians’ Jordanian citizenship, argued that in 1960 Jordan had extended its naturalisation rules to all Palestinians, added that “more research is required” to establish what had happened to that decision since, and wrote: “I benefited from our talk the other day.”
Shehadeh replied at legal length, and disagreed: in his view there was no legal basis for the claim that all Palestinians could obtain Jordanian citizenship as of right. Gazit’s records and studies serve researchers to this day, those who agree with him and those who dispute him.
A fork in the road
Write a history you were part of.
Write as a witness
The price: Personal memory, with all its biases.
Write as a scholar
The price: Facing the documents, even when they are unflattering.
And what happened?
He chose the documents: his books rest on the archives, and along the way he corresponded even with those who disagreed with him, such as the Palestinian lawyer Aziz Shehadeh.
During his years of research, the international landscape changed: communist governments in Eastern Europe fell in 1989, and the Soviet Union dissolved in 1991. The confrontation between the blocs that had framed much of his service came to an end.
After his retirement his tie with the United States took a new direction.
MeanwhileTwo centres, one people
After his retirement his tie with the United States took a new direction. Back in Jerusalem he headed the American Jewish Committee’s Israel office, on Ethiopia Street, the family relates.
In 1982 he published “America and Israel” in Partisan Review, on the friendship between the two countries and Israel’s fears of relying on it, and the same issue listed him as a visiting professor at Boston University.
In 1984 ten young Israelis, aged 28 to 38, were selected under his guidance for an American Jewish Committee programme to get to know American Jewry, and on their return they met him to review what they had learned and how to improve the programme.
That year he also sent Rabbi Marc Tanenbaum, with a handwritten note, material he had found in the Foreign Ministry archive: “This is the ‘crop’ after a search in the M.F.A. archive.”
A fork in the road
How do you connect young Israelis to an American Jewry they know only from afar?
Explain it from here
The price: A flat, distant picture.
Send them there
The price: A costly programme, whose participants must be chosen with care.
And what happened?
In 1984 the participants were chosen under his guidance, and on their return they met him to review what they had learned.
In the 1980s most of the world’s Jews lived in two places: Israel and the United States. Organisations such as the American Jewish Committee looked for ways to bring them closer, and to let young Israelis get to know communities they had seen only from afar.
Mordechai’s life
2016
Home and familyaged 93
A story that stays with us
Mordechai Gazit died on 29 May 2016, aged 93, sixty-eight years and ten days after he was wounded in the Jewish Quarter.
MeanwhileFamily memory and the public record
Mordechai Gazit died on 29 May 2016, aged 93, sixty-eight years and ten days after he was wounded in the Jewish Quarter. He left behind books, articles and files in archives from which one can learn today about the founding years of Israel’s foreign policy.
His name appears in some twenty documents of the official documentary series of United States diplomacy, from the John F. KennedyPresident of the United States, 1961–1963. Gazit wrote a book on his policy.What they wanted: To prevent the spread of nuclear weapons, including at Dimona, and to build ties with the Arab states as well.More on John F. Kennedy in “People and events” → years to the Ford years. A company commander in 1948, director-general of two ministries, political adviser to two prime ministers, ambassador and scholar: few served the state on so many fronts, and for so many years.
And to his family he left the memory of Motke: husband, father and grandfather.
His life connects the defence of Jerusalem, the development of Israel’s foreign service and the diplomatic effort to reach agreements. Alongside family memories, contemporary documents and testimony offer a way to revisit the events and understand his part in them.
Mordechai Gazit gave the state almost his entire adult life. He belonged to the generation that fought for its founding, and then helped build its foreign service, from the first embassies to the rooms where peace was negotiated.
The family remembers the price as well: years in which the state came first, more than once at the expense of home and personal life. In 1980, speaking of the academic ambitions he had set aside, he put it simply: he had chosen “serving the new state rather than minding my own little shop.”