Historical context and questions to explore
December 1960. A secret comes out in Washington: in the Negev, with French help, Israel is building a nuclear reactor. The incoming Kennedy administration, fearing the spread of nuclear weapons in the Middle East, wants answers. From then on, every conversation between the two countries is also held in Dimona’s shadow.
Washington demanded information and visits to the site. David Ben-GurionIsrael’s first Prime Minister.What they wanted: A strong state, and allies beyond the ring of hostility.More on David Ben-Gurion in “People and events” → agreed to American visits, the first of which took place in 1961.
Why it mattered. The Dimona reactor is among the most fateful decisions in Israel’s history, and the way the issue was handled with Washington in the 1960s shaped relations between the two countries for generations. The American visits were the first test of whether Israel could keep both the secret and the friendship.
A question to think about
How do you answer an ally that demands transparency without revealing what Israel had decided not to reveal, and without losing its trust?
Why it was hard. Israel sought secrecy and freedom of action; the United States sought transparency. Both wanted to strengthen the relationship without letting the issue damage it.
His part: In 1961, from the Washington embassy, Gazit coordinated the first visit of American scientists to the Dimona reactor.
In spring 1961, Gazit coordinated with the U.S. Department of State the first visit by American scientists to Dimona. The National Security Archive’s document collection describes his discussions about the timing of the visit and the arrangements for it.
The talks with the State Department moved step by step. On 17 April 1961 Assistant Secretary Jones proposed to him that the visit be kept “quiet” rather than “secret”. On 1 May Deputy Assistant Secretary Armin Meyer discussed the visit with him. And on 16 May Philip Farley, the Secretary of State’s Special Assistant for Atomic Energy, reported a conversation with him about the visit and its purposes.
On 30 May 1961, two weeks later, David Ben-GurionIsrael’s first Prime Minister.What they wanted: A strong state, and allies beyond the ring of hostility.More on David Ben-Gurion in “People and events” → and John F. KennedyPresident of the United States, 1961–1963. Gazit wrote a book on his policy.What they wanted: To prevent the spread of nuclear weapons, including at Dimona, and to build ties with the Arab states as well.More on John F. Kennedy in “People and events” → met at the Waldorf Astoria in New York, with Dimona at the top of the agenda. On 7 June Gazit sent the Foreign Ministry the Israeli record of the meeting drawn up by Ambassador Avraham HarmanIsrael’s ambassador in Washington, 1959–1968; Gazit was his deputy at the embassy.What they wanted: A close tie to the Kennedy administration, without the Dimona dispute damaging it.More on Avraham Harman in “People and events” →, with an attachment on the “atomic reactor”, under his own cover letter. The document is kept today at the Israel State Archives.
This was another aspect of his work as Minister at the embassy: attending to the practical details of a sensitive issue within the relationship between the Ben-Gurion and Kennedy administrations.Diplomatic recordThe First American Visit to DimonaDiplomatic recordWilson Center Digital Archive — documents on Mordechai GazitDiplomatic recordAmbassador Harman’s record of the Ben-Gurion/Kennedy meeting, sent with a cover letter by Mordechai Gazit
Sources and reading notes (3)
The lead source
Wilson Center Digital Archive — documents on Mordechai Gazit ↗Wilson Center, Washington. State Department memoranda of conversation from April–June 1961 on the American visit to Dimona, and a record of Gazit’s meeting with Victor Louis on 15 June 1973. The record is kept at the Israel State Archives (Record Group 130, Foreign Ministry, file 5973/4) and was published in English by Guy Laron (CWIHP e-Dossier 31, 2012).
- Diplomatic Records[WC1] Wilson Center Digital Archive — documents on Mordechai Gazit ↗
Wilson Center, Washington. State Department memoranda of conversation from April–June 1961 on the American visit to Dimona, and a record of Gazit’s meeting with Victor Louis on 15 June 1973. The record is kept at the Israel State Archives (Record Group 130, Foreign Ministry, file 5973/4) and was published in English by Guy Laron (CWIHP e-Dossier 31, 2012).
- Diplomatic Records[WCG61] Ambassador Harman’s record of the Ben-Gurion/Kennedy meeting, sent with a cover letter by Mordechai Gazit ↗
Wilson Center Digital Archive, 7 June 1961; Israel State Archives, file 130.02/3294/7. Published in Avner Cohen and William Burr, eds., National Security Archive Electronic Briefing Book 547 (2016).
- Diplomatic Records[D12] The First American Visit to Dimona ↗
National Security Archive, George Washington University. Introduction to a collection of documents about arrangements for the 1961 visit.